A pensioner who purchased a cottage for their son but retained legal title is seeking clarity on tax liability after the son began renting the property while traveling abroad. Tax expert Heather Rogers explains that responsibility depends on whether the son is considered the beneficial owner, urging immediate legal clarification to avoid unexpected tax bills.
A pensioner who purchased a small cottage for their son three years ago but kept the property in their own name is facing uncertainty regarding tax liability after the son began renting out the home while living abroad.
The individual, identified only as J.P., confirmed that they retain legal ownership of the property. However, the son has taken possession of the rental income, receiving £858 each month after agency fees have been deducted. The pensioner noted that they do not receive any portion of this rent and are questioning whether they can avoid the associated tax burden despite being the registered owner.
J.P., who is a pensioner but continues to work and holds savings, acknowledged that they already pay income tax. Nevertheless, they expressed concern about the potential for an additional tax liability arising from the rental profits generated by the property. The core of the query hinges on the distinction between legal ownership and the right to receive income, as well as the practical difficulties of transferring the property title while the son is overseas.
Heather Rogers, founder and owner of Aston Accountancy, addressed the complexity of determining who is entitled to the profits from the rental of the property and, consequently, who is responsible for the tax bill. Rogers emphasized that the answer is not straightforward and depends heavily on the specific arrangements made between the parent and the son at the time of purchase.
From the information provided, it is clear that J.P. remains the legal owner because the cottage is held in their name. In standard property transactions, the person who holds the legal title and is registered at the Land Registry as the legal owner is typically the same person who benefits from the rights to the property. This includes the right to sell the property, determine occupancy, and benefit from the proceeds of any sale.
However, Rogers explained that there is a distinct concept known as beneficial ownership. For income tax purposes, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) looks to the person who is receiving or entitled to the profits to determine tax liability. The beneficial owner has the right to benefit from the property even though their name does not appear on the legal title.
A beneficial owner may be someone who has invested money into the property, has the right to live in the property under an agreement without paying rent, or is entitled to a share of the proceeds upon sale. In such cases, the individual’s name does not appear on the legal title, yet they hold significant rights.
To avoid disputes and clarify these rights, Rogers noted that when there is a beneficial owner, an agreement is normally drawn up. This can take the form of a Deed of Trust or an express agreement. An express agreement can be oral or written, though a written agreement is preferable, and a Deed of Trust is considered the most robust option. Such documents identify the rights of the beneficial owner, including how they are entitled to benefit from the property, whether they have a right to the income or residence, their contribution to the property, and what happens upon sale.
The determination of whether J.P.’s son is the beneficial owner and therefore liable for the tax bills depends on several factors. Rogers asked whether there is any written agreement identifying that the son has the right to the rental income. She also questioned who the landlord is in the eyes of the letting agency. If J.P. is the landlord and the money is paid to them before being handed to the son, there is a strong argument that J.P. controls the income and is entitled to it. In this scenario, gifting the monies to the son would not necessarily make him the beneficial owner, and HMRC would likely deem J.P. liable for the tax.
Conversely, if the son is the named landlord and receives the funds directly, he could be deemed the beneficial owner. This would make him liable for the tax, even if J.P. assists with property management or deals with the rental agent on his behalf while he is abroad. If both are named as landlords, they could both be assessed for tax equally, depending on practical arrangements.
Rogers stated her expectation that unless a specific agreement is in place, J.P., as the legal owner, is considered the landlord. She urged J.P. to consult a solicitor to establish either a Deed of Trust or an express agreement. This would ensure that any rights the son has as a beneficial owner are clearly defined, including the right to rental profits. Once such an arrangement is in place, the son would be taxed on the income rather than J.P.
If the son is clearly identified as the beneficial owner of the income, he will need to pay tax on the rental profit because it arises in the UK and is taxable there, regardless of his residency status. He would need to register for self-assessment.
Rogers confirmed that the most straightforward course of action would be for J.P. to gift the property to the son, making him both the legal and beneficial owner. This transfer would be classed as a Potentially Exempt Transfer (PET) and would fall outside J.P.’s estate for inheritance tax purposes within seven years.
However, there could be capital gains tax due if the property has increased in value since it was purchased. J.P. might be able to claim Private Residence Relief for the period during which the son lived in it as his main residence. This relief is available for trusts if a person is entitled to live in a property as their main residence under the terms of the trust. Rogers suggested that if a Deed of Trust exists or can be established, there is likely an implied trust because the son had the right to occupy the property.
The determination of beneficial ownership can be complicated and has led to numerous tax enquiries. In two recent Court of Appeal cases, either receipt or entitlement was given as the definition of who pays tax on profits. In a First Tier Tribunal case, the tribunal found that the person who should pay tax on profits is the one who receives and controls them, even if the property is owned by someone else.
Rogers, who serves as a tax columnist, noted that she is ready to answer questions on various tax topics, including tax codes, inheritance tax, income tax, and capital gains tax. She advised readers to email their questions to her designated address, noting that while she will do her best to reply in a forthcoming monthly column, she cannot answer everyone or correspond privately. She clarified that nothing in her replies constitutes regulated financial advice.
Readers are encouraged to include a daytime contact number with their messages, which will be kept confidential and not used for marketing purposes. If Rogers is unable to answer a question, individuals can seek help from MoneyHelper, a government-backed organization providing free assistance on financial matters. Its contact number is 0800 011 3797. Additional resources are available for those seeking help with tax, including sources of free professional advice for the elderly or those on low income.
G.Luthra--BD